July 16, 2022

Chronicles of The Lost Daughters by Debarati Mukhopadhyay | Book Review

 



Title: Chronicles of The Lost Daughters
Author: Debarati Mukhopadhyay
Translator: Arunava Sinha
Publisher: HarperCollins India
Genre: Historical Fiction
Pages: 336
Buy Online: Amazon

 

‘...do you know what it will mean if we don’t get boys for our daughters? Do you realize the kind of trouble there will be if Awpala isn’t married before she’s twelve?’

Debarati Mukhopadhyay’s Chronicles of the Lost Daughters is an enthralling historical fiction, translated by Arunava Sinha, Centered around the state of women of nineteenth-century Bengal. It is originally published in the Bengali, title is ‘Naraach’ that simply means – Weapon.

The story begins with Krishnoshundor Chattopadhyay, a penniless brahmin, is trapped into an offer of decent job. He grabs this as an only escape for his sister, Bhubonmani – who has been faced a hellish journey. She endured a child marriage, widowhood and sexual assault – that too, at the age of sixteen. The so-called learned man of society grabbed this opportunity to fulfil their malicious desires, and they declared shamelessly ‘A raped woman must of course perform strict penance. In this case the rapists are from another religion, which means that even if she herself is a brahmoni, the act has made a mleccha out of her. She will be restored to her own people if a high-born brahmon is willing to accept her services for two fortnights.’

Her brother, Krishnoshundor was too innocent to decipher these words at first, and when things got cleared to him, he put questions at the religious texts, ‘How very unfair! So Bhubonmoni would have to be raped for a month because some criminals had raped her once? This was utterly unjust, which shastras asked for this? Krishnoshundor could sign an oath it was impossible for such a thing to be written in any of the shastras. It was impossible.’


Besides the deep level of research, Debarati Mukhopadhyay took a creative freedom and presented many historical figures, Dr. Kamdambini Ganguly, Tagore and Nawab of Oudh – Wajid Ali Shah to us. Apart from this, there are many subplots running around the core theme, such as women education, widow remarriage, caste-disabled society, child marriage is one of them, basically that was times of Bengal renaissance.

‘That was the age of shruti. Women enjoyed high social standing, they used to study the Vedas, they used to teach. They were not yet considered anyone’s property. A wife was her husband’s partner in every sense, not just his companion in bed as she is now. But those days are gone. The diagnoses of the learned men, Muslim rule and patriarchy in society have gradually pushed women back into their homes and turned them into puppets. It is the age of the Manusamhita. The woman will be subservient to her father in childhood, to her husband after marriage, and to her son when she is a widow. She will never have an independent life. How can you speak of your own daughters remaining unmarried in such circumstances?’

What is the role of Brahma Samaaj movement? How did Bhubonmoni’s life turn out, once she joins the movement?
Why did Wajid Ali Shah created a mini-Lucknow in Calcutta?

The life story of Kadombini is so inspiring that adds the value to the story. I quite liked the determinate character of Bhubonmoni’s sister-in-law, who she seeks her as a mother. 

With crisp, and clear writing, this book feels like an exhilarating journey. And the translation of Arunava Sinha uplifts the reading experience. Chronicals of the Lost Daughters is a heart-wrenching historical saga. Regardless, interlinked stories, interlaced characters, this book is such a page-turner. Recommended!

 

Synopsis:

When unspeakable tragedy befalls Bhubonmoni, a young widow, she must leave her village along with her brother, Krishnoshundor, and his family. Ensnared by the wily entrepreneur Nobokishore Dutta, they end up in an overcrowded depot near a port, soon to be packed into a ship sailing to Surinam, where they will be sold as sugarcane plantation slaves. But Fate has other plans. Bhubonmoni finds herself being led away from the port and her family to be stowed away in a secret location in Calcutta. Not too far away, a young rebel Shourendro is swept up by the ideas of the Brahmo Samaj. Meanwhile in Metiabruz, a shy musician Chondronath impresses the exiled Nawab of Lucknow with his art. None of them know it yet, but the stars are aligning despite overwhelming odds for them to meet under curious circumstances…Set against the vibrant background of late nineteenth-century Bengal, Debarati Mukhopadhyay’s beautifully woven novel brings together the glory and the decadence of colonial times. Fast-paced and thrilling, with a lively cast of characters including historical figures such as Nawab Wajid Ali Shah, Rabindranath Tagore, and Dr Kadambini Ganguly, Chronicles of the Lost Daughters is an unforgettable saga

 

About The Author


Debarati Mukhopadhyay is one of the most popular authors of contemporary Bengali literature. A young Government officer by profession, she has written more than 20 bestselling novels including Narach, Dakat Raja, Glanirbhabati Bharat, Shikhandi, Ishwar Jakhan Bandi and Aghore Ghimiye Shiva. Her corporate world novel Dasgupta Travels was shortlisted for the Sahitya Akademi Yuva Puraskar in 2021. Many of her novels, such as Narak Sanket, Ranrkahini, and Shikhandi have been adapted for the silver screen. Debarati is a prolific writer and contributes regularly to Bengal’s prominent literary magazines and journals. As an officer, bestselling author, travel-enthusiast, an amateur violinist and mother to an infant, Debarati is considered a youth icon in Bengal who volunteers her time to guide government-job aspirants. A widely recognized public speaker, Debarati can be often found delivering motivational talks at educational seminars, conferences, and at the halls of Ramakrishna Mission.  

 

This post is powered by Blogchatter Review Program.

 

 


July 14, 2022

Leila Mottley’s Nightcrawling



‘Mama used to tell me that blood is everything, but I think we're all out here unlearning that sentiment, scraping our knees, and asking strangers to patch us back up.’

Leila Mottley’s Nightcrawling is a brutal, yet compelling read. It’s an honest documentation of survival and law system in human-society, more than that It provides you a lens to introspect. 

The story based on a true event, Oakland scandal of 2015. Mottley has a fearless voice, compassionate heart and a clear vision. Although, it is a horrifying account of one’s life, still I am amazed by its breathing prose.

Nightcrawling is a dark novel, which casts light on the hidden life of our seventeen years old protagonist. Her name is Kia. She lives with her brother, Marcus, in a slum apartment. Brother makes her believe that he loves her. He has delusional dreams. He doesn’t make any efforts to provide basic facilities to Kia. When the apartment owner threatens to rent hike, she is left with no-choice but ‘Nightcrawling’. She is just a teen - deprived of parents - who is eager to make a living, to survive, to endure. Then, there is another character, named Trevor, who is only sunshine in her life, though they are not connected by blood, but the way she cares for a nine-years old motherless kid, I could explore empathetic side of her. The chaos is temporary, that’s what she thinks. The entry of local police coloured this survival story into the most devastated account of injustice.

Leila Mottley approached essential themes in her debut, for instance: gender injustice, police misconduct, prostitution, human rights abuses, race discrimination and dearth.

Mottley’s writing enthrals you with the opening line itself, ‘The swimming pool is filled with dog shit and Dee’s laughter mocks us at dawn.”

Are there any cons? It’s just the length, I wish it were crisp, and well edited at places, so that I could visualize this powerful story in an intimate manner.

Apart from the captivating story and rich prose style, I have been pondering over the age of writer. she was not even 18 when she actually started working on this project. It’s a powerful story, undoubtedly a well-deserved entry into Oprah book club. 

 ‘...and I don’t really got nothing to fear about dying in the first place. I just think that the stars might line up and trail into an otherworld. Doesn’t have to be a better world because that probably doesn’t exist, but I think it is something else. Somewhere where the people walk a little different. Maybe they speak in hums. Maybe they all got the same face or maybe they don’t have faces at all. When I have enough time to stare at the sky, I imagine I might be lucky enough to catch glimpses of the something.’